Or, more recently, in an underdog slum girl who communicated with whirling clouds of dust and ghost-ridden pigeons. I'm saying Pierce failed to make it feel real to me, and it's a sad ending to a writer-reader relationship that once had me deeply emotionally invested in a cross-dressing, goddess-touched knight trainee and her magical cat companion.

But I'm not saying I refuse to believe the characters would act a certain way because they're Good (i.e. There were narrative jumps, especially when it came to character motivations, which I simply did not buy. But I have to say my disappointment with 'Mastiff' isn't limited to the constraints of its ambition. It's obvious my own preference colors my review. The last two in the trilogy are a bit of Beka the Super-Dog: capable of toppling insidious political/economic/cultural corruption in a single book, along with Appropriate Sidekicks. I disagree, or at least, I disagree that it tackles them with the same immediacy and deeply personal stakes introduced in 'Terrier.' That book was a young woman's struggle to find her place in a corrupt-yet-beloved community, where her attempts to find a solid moral ground to stand on were further complicated by complex friendships. I'm sure some people will vehemently insist 'Mastiff' contains these issues as well. If you want a story that tackles internal issues as well the external - such as identity and ideology, and the conflict between idealism and realism - then you're better off reading 'Terrier' and leaving it at that. If you enjoy Issue stories, wherein Bad Things are given an unflinching and immediate portrayal, and there are at least one or two Shocking Twists before the wrap, 'Bloodhound' and 'Mastiff' are for you.

Kirkus nailed it when they compared Pierce's approach to a police procedural, and it's this approach which either raises or damns Beka's story depending on the audience. With 'Mastiff,' I realized Pierce is no longer writing the kind of story I like to read. With 'Bloodhound' I was less thrilled, but since I got to spend more time with the amazing, admirable Beka, I wrote it off as a sophomore slump. 'Terrier' is one of my favorite Pierce books, quite an upset considering the lens of middle-school nostalgia through which I see the Alanna quartet.

126 of 142 people found the following review helpful.

The legend of beka cooper